The skill of one man and the coordination of a whole company are two different things. Weapons & Formations is about the second: how weapons are paired, how ranks are drawn up, how a company acts as one body. What matters in this learning is how it turned the strength of single soldiers into discipline that could be arranged and taught.
First the instruments. Yu Chenglong (a council member of the China Yin-Shang Culture Society and former deputy director of the Research Institute of the National Museum of China) says that Yinxu has yielded over a hundred two-wheeled chariots yoked to a pair of horses, found with weapons such as dagger-axes and arrowheads; the Annals of Zhou in the Records of the Grand Historian says King Wu of Zhou “led three hundred war chariots, three thousand tiger-like guards and forty-five thousand armored men, to attack King Zhou in the east.” The Rites of Zhou, in the Records of Examination of Craftsmen, sets the dimensions of the dagger-axe as a standard: “the ge is two cun wide, the tang twice that, the hu three times, the blade four times,” and prescribes the ratio of copper to tin: “divide the metal into four parts with tin one: that is the mix for ge and ji,” which is not the same recipe as the “six parts with tin one” used for bells and cauldrons. This end joins Ritual Bronzes: both are bronze, yet ritual vessels and weapons each have their own mix. The Master of Weapons in the Rites of Zhou, Offices of Summer, “has charge of the five weapons and five shields,” and at sacrifices must also “hand weapons to the dancers”: weapons also belong to ritual, which leads to Rituals. The Book of Songs, in “No Clothes” of the Qin odes, sings “when the king raises his troops, I will mend my ge and spear and share your hate,” “I will mend my spear and ji and set out with you,” so the ge, spear and ji in the song become the pledge of “sharing hate” and “setting out together.”
Then the formations. The Zuo Commentary, for the fifth year of Duke Huan, records the battle between the army of Zheng and the lords led by the Zhou king, and the Zheng army “made the fish-scale formation: chariots first, foot soldiers behind, the foot soldiers filling the gaps.” The commentary cites the Sima Fa: “In chariot warfare, twenty-five chariots make a pian; the chariots stand in front and the files of five come next, filling the gaps and covering the holes in the pian.” Chariots in front and infantry mending the seams: the name and layout of a formation were already written in the histories. Sun Bin's Art of War opens with “there are ten formations”: the square, the round, the sparse, the dense, the wedge-shaped, the wild-goose, the hook-shaped, the “dark vessel,” the fire and the water, each with its advantage; the wedge is for breaking through, and the wild-goose line for supporting archers in succession. The Records of the Grand Historian says Sun Bin was a later descendant of Sun Wu, and this line leads to Art of War.
Formations can be turned into objects. Pit One of the terracotta army holds an estimated six thousand pottery figures and horses and also a large quantity of bronze weapons, and the display of holdings lists Qin bronze ge, ji, pi and swords; the three pits together hold about eight thousand pottery figures and horses and tens of thousands of bronze arrowheads. Terracotta Army deals with these very pits: figures and weapons were buried together by the pit, and the finer points of their arrangement are to be seen in that class.
In the Ming, Qi Jiguang wrote this learning into the rules of small squads. The History of Ming records that when he came to Zhejiang and saw that the garrison troops did not know how to fight, he asked to recruit three thousand men, “taught them thrusting and striking, using long and short weapons in turn,” “made formations according to the lay of the land,” and so “the Qi family army became famous under heaven”; in the war against the Japanese raiders “in nine battles in succession, all were victories.” The Jixiao Xinshu describes the mandarin-duck formation: “Two shield bearers stand in a row; a wolf-tooth bamboo man follows each shield, to guard the shield bearer's back. Two long spears are assigned to each shield and each bamboo man. Short weapons stand ready, so that when a long spear has thrust and is spent, they strike at once,” “the bamboo man rescues the shield, the long spear rescues the bamboo man, the short weapon rescues the long spear,” and it sets a rule of military law: anyone who has heard the drum and still hesitates to advance “is beheaded at once under military law.” Huang Pumin and Xiong Jianping sum this up as “long weapons guard the short, short weapons rescue the long.” But Qi himself says in the opening of the book that methods against the Japanese raiders would need rethinking on the northern plains: “On the open northern plains, where the ground is different and enemy horse come in tens of thousands, their numbers unlike ours, galloping like wind and rain and unable to be stopped, how could these methods be used?” At Jizhen the History of Ming records that he proposed chariot camps: “each chariot pushed and pulled by four men, in battle forming a square with the mounted and foot soldiers inside,” “when the enemy comes, firearms fire first,” “and when they come close, the foot soldiers advance in ranks with anti-cavalry barriers, interspersed with long spears and bamboo wolf-teeth.” The formation thus gained firearms, and the change described in Firearms Evolution entered the art of formations here.
Without this learning, Chinese weapons would be only copper and iron and soldiers only heads: there would be no mending of seams by “chariots first, foot soldiers behind,” no rescue by “long guarding short,” and so no formation that could be taught, drilled and changed to suit the ground.
“The bamboo man rescues the shield, the long spear rescues the bamboo man, the short weapon rescues the long spear”: these lines of the mandarin-duck formation say how a squad covers for one another. This learning of arrangement has early texts and objects behind it: the Records of Examination of Craftsmen fixed the dimensions of the ge and its mix of copper and tin, the Zheng army's fish-scale formation put “chariots first, foot soldiers behind, the foot soldiers filling the gaps,” Sun Bin listed ten formations, and Pit One of the Qin mausoleum held pottery figures buried with bronze weapons. Qi Jiguang also warned that on the northern plains the methods used against the Japanese raiders would need rethinking, and at Jizhen he had firearms fire first. Weapons and formations changed again and again with the ground, yet arrangements that could be written down and taught were handed on.
Weapons and Formations is the class in the chapter on Strategies on arms and battle order. It covers how hand weapons and ranks fought together from the Shang on: the bronze dagger-axe and the joint action of chariots and infantry at Yinxu, Sun Bin's writing on formations in the Warring States, and Qi Jiguang's mandarin duck formation in the Ming.