The Shiji, in the Pingzhun shu, first records that Dongguo Xianyang and Kong Jin were made deputies to the Grand Minister of Agriculture in charge of salt and iron: Xianyang was "a great salt boiler of Qi," Kong Jin "a great smelter of Nanyang," and "hence Zheng Dangshi recommended them." The next year the great army marched out against the Xiongnu, "rewards of 500,000 gold were given, and over a hundred thousand Han horses died," and "at that time the treasury was short"; then the five-zhu coin was cast. Only after this does the book record the Grand Minister of Agriculture presenting the words of the salt-and-iron deputies Kong Jin and Xianyang: "The mountains and seas are the storehouse of Heaven and Earth; they should belong to the Privy Treasury, but Your Majesty does not keep them private and gives them to the Grand Minister of Agriculture to aid the levies. We ask to recruit the people to provide their own costs, and, using state vessels, to boil salt, the state supplying the pans." The memorial goes on to ask that private salt boiling and iron casting be punished, and the book says that afterwards "the path of office grew mixed, no selection was made, and many were merchants." This passage of the Shiji gives no reign year. The Zizhi tongjian, at the opening of Yuanshou 4 (which the page marks as 119 BCE), records that "Dongguo Xianyang and Kong Jin were made deputies to the Grand Minister of Agriculture, in charge of salt and iron," and an edict that "those among the people who dare to cast iron wares or boil salt privately shall have the left foot shackled and their tools confiscated"; it does not carry the memorial on "the mountains and seas." The two books order the events differently, and each is followed as it stands.
Whether salt and iron should stay a state monopoly was argued in Shiyuan 6. The Hanshu, Annals of Zhaodi, records that in the 2nd month (lunar) of Shiyuan 6 an edict had officials ask the worthies and literati recommended by the commanderies what the people suffered, and "debated abolishing the salt-and-iron monopoly and the liquor monopoly"; in the autumn, the 7th month (lunar), "the liquor monopoly offices were abolished, and the people were allowed to declare liquor by law and pay a tax, wine selling for four coins a sheng"; the annals do not say that salt and iron were also abolished. Shiyuan 6 is 81 BCE. The Yantie lun records the exchange: the literati say "we wish to abolish the salt, iron and liquor monopolies and the transport levies, to advance the root and retire the branch"; the grand master answers "the borders lacked supplies, so salt and iron were taken up, the liquor monopoly set up, and the transport levies placed, to multiply goods and add to wealth and to help the frontier's costs," and adds "farmers, merchants, craftsmen and officials each get what they want and withdraw after trading"; the literati say "to show the people profit makes custom thin." The literati quote Confucius, the grand master quotes the Guanzi.
The Tang made salt a large item in the treasury. In the Xin Tang shu, Treatise on Food and Goods: in Qianyuan 1 (758) "Di Wu Qi, commissioner of salt and iron and of coinage, first changed the salt law, setting up supervisory offices at places near the mountains, seas, wells and pans, calling the idle people who made salt tinghu and exempting them from miscellaneous labor," and then "monopolized all salt under heaven, selling it at a hundred coins above the market price per dou, at 110 coins." Liu Yan instead had "the tinghu sell to merchants, who could go where they liked," and "when Yan first arrived, the salt revenue was only 400,000 strings a year; by the end of Dali, over six million strings. Of the taxes under heaven, salt revenue made half." The same chapter records that Liu Yan set up regulating salt in the Yangzi and Lingnan regions far from salt, "the state taking a large profit without the people feeling the price"; after Liu Yan's salt law was in place, the same chapter, describing the time when Bao Ji ran salt and iron, says "poor people in distant villages, burdened by high valuations, even went without salt."
In the Song, salt revenue was tangled with paper money. The Song shi records that in Xining 2 an edict set up a jiaozi bureau at Luzhou, but the transport office held that if the law were applied "salt and alum would not sell," and it was abolished; in year 4 it was applied again in Shaanxi, and "the Yongxingjun salt-voucher office was abolished"; in the Chongning years it says "the qianyin were meant to stand in for salt vouchers." Here salt is not just one commodity; in the Song shi it keeps meeting jiaozi and qianyin, and the line of Jiaozi Banknotes is joined to it through salt.
Passes and sea-trade offices are the other end of the same matter. The Ming shi records that in the early Ming foreign states bringing tribute might carry goods to trade, "so maritime trade offices were set up, with directors in charge, in order to communicate with the foreign peoples and curb crafty merchants"; in early Hongwu one was set up at Huangdu in Taicang and soon abolished, then set up again at Ningbo, Quanzhou and Guangzhou. In early Yongle, men of the state of Lani in the Western Seas carried pepper to trade with the people, officials asked to tax it, and the emperor said: "The commercial tax is meant by the state to curb the people who chase the branch trade, not to profit. Now foreigners come from afar out of admiration; to take their gain, how much would it bring, and how great the loss of dignity."
This line still exists today. The State Council's Plan for Reform of the Salt Industry of 22 April 2016 (published 5 May) writes of "carrying out structural reform on the supply side while keeping the edible-salt monopoly," "keeping the wholesale monopoly," and "no longer approving new designated salt producers"; it also lifts the limits on regions of production and sale and sets a transition period (to 31 December 2016), providing that "from 1 January 2017 the prices of all salt products are freed and the permit for transporting edible salt is abolished." The plan keeps the monopoly and at the same time provides for freeing the price.
Why is it canon? What can be checked is a few things. In the Han, the reasons for putting salt and iron under the state are told differently in the Shiji and the Yantie lun, and in Shiyuan 6 the two sides argued it out, leaving the Yantie lun; in the Tang, by the end of Dali "of the taxes under heaven, salt revenue made half," and poor people in distant villages also "even went without salt"; the Yongle emperor said the commercial tax was to "curb the people who chase the branch trade," not to take gain from those who came from afar; and today's plan writes keeping the monopoly and freeing the price into one document. The state wanted salt revenue, and the literati called this "competing with the people for gain": both were present already in the debate of Shiyuan 6.
Salt monopoly also reaches into other canons. For Jiaozi Banknotes, the Song shi says the qianyin were meant to replace salt vouchers; for Currency Evolution, in the same passage of the Shiji white metal money was made and the five-zhu coin recast; for Tea-Horse Frontier Trade, the Ming shi writes "in the east there are horse markets, in the west tea markets, all to manage the border and save on garrison costs"; for Merchant Guild Commerce, Sang Hongyang was "the son of a merchant of Luoyang," and, with Kong Jin and Dongguo Xianyang, "spoke of profit down to the finest hair of autumn."
Of the state's hold on salt and iron, Kong Jin and his colleague in the Shiji wrote "to aid the levies," the grand master in the Yantie lun said "to help the frontier's costs," and the literati said "competing with the people for gain"; both sides' words were kept. In the Tang, salt revenue by the end of Dali made half of "the taxes under heaven," while poor people in distant villages "even went without salt"; in the Song the qianyin "were meant to stand in for salt vouchers"; the Yongle emperor said the commercial tax was to "curb the people who chase the branch trade"; and the plan of 2016 keeps the monopoly while providing for freed prices. Some of the time the books write down why the levy was made, as with the Han's levies and frontier costs and Yongle's curbing of the branch trade; at other times what they leave is figures and consequences.
Salt & Transit Monopolies is the class in the chapter on Commerce on state monopolies and the taxes on passes and markets. The state took everyday goods such as salt and iron into official hands, and also levied duties at passes and at the offices for overseas trade, and drew revenue from both.