Bamboo slips, wooden tablets and silk were the common writing materials before paper, writing on them flourished in the Warring States, and manuscripts, maps and archives are told here too.

Shang dynasty to Eastern Jin

Before paper, writing rode on bamboo and wooden slips and on silk. In the Shangshu chapter Duo shi, the king of Zhou tells the many officers of Yin: “The forebears of Yin had ce and dian, and Yin overturned the mandate of Xia,” using the ce and the dian to speak of how an earlier dynasty rose and fell. Xu Shen, in the preface to the Shuowen jiezi, says: “What is set down on bamboo and silk is called a book.” Slips were bound together one by one, and each held few characters. The Hanshu treatise Yiwen zhi says that Liu Xiang, collating the three schools of the Shangshu, the Ouyang and the greater and lesser Xiahou, with the ancient-script text, found “one slip missing from the Jiu gao and two from the Shao gao,” and adds: “where a slip held twenty-five characters, the missing part was twenty-five characters, and where a slip held twenty-two, the missing part was twenty-two”: one slip lost meant twenty-five or twenty-two characters lost.

To write much was to carry much. The Shiji, in its chapter on the jesters, records that when Dongfang Shuo first came to Chang'an and sent in a memorial, he “used three thousand tablets”; “the officer of the carriage gate had two men lift it together, and they could barely manage”; Emperor Wu “read it for two months before he finished.” The Mozi, in the chapter Guiyi, says: “Mozi traveled south to Wei, and the cart was loaded with a great many books.” The Zhuangzi, in the chapter Tianxia, says: “Hui Shi had many ways, and his books filled five carts.” The arguments of the masters had to be made into chapters and scrolls and loaded on carts to travel; this is the ground that the essays discussed under Masters' Prose stand on. The Yiwen zhi looks back at the Warring States and says: “In the Warring States, the alliances and counter-alliances ran across and down; true and false contended; the words of the masters were mixed in confusion.” What survives of all that confusion was written on slips and silk.

Slips and silk also depended on the state to be kept. The Yiwen zhi writes that after Qin “burned and destroyed the writings,” “when Han arose it mended the failings of Qin, gathered in books on a large scale, and opened wide the way to present them. By the time of Emperor Xiaowu, books were missing and slips lost, the rites were in ruin and music had fallen away; the emperor sighed and said, 'I am deeply troubled.' So he set up the plan for storing books and appointed officers to copy books, and everything down to the masters' commentaries filled the palace archive.” The same chapter records that at the end of Emperor Wu's reign, Prince Gong of Lu, pulling down the old house of Confucius, found the ancient-script Shangshu and the Liji, Analects and Xiaojing, “all in ancient characters”; the books on these slips were part of the source of the classics discussed under Confucian Classics. Sima Qian, in the Taishigong zixu, says he “put in order the records of the stone chamber and the metal casket”; the Records of the Grand Historian also relied on archives kept in this way.

What came out of the ground bears out the line. The Zeng Hou Yi tomb slips shown by the Hubei Provincial Museum are the earliest bamboo slips found so far, more than 2,400 years old; they were found in 1978 in the tomb of Marquis Yi of Zeng at Suizhou, Hubei, and 240 slips carry writing, about 7,000 characters in all, mainly recording the chariots and horses used at the burial, with 39 names of chariots and 207 horses. The Warring States bamboo slips acquired by Tsinghua University came in 2008, number about 2,500, were copied around 305 BC, and are mostly classics and histories, among them a Fu Yue zhi ming that differs from the chapter of that name in the ancient-script Shangshu which appeared in the Eastern Jin; the first batch of texts is held to have “brought back the Shangshu and similar writings.” The Xinian has 138 slips and records history from the early Western Zhou to the early Warring States, with many events not found in the received texts, and may correct the Zuozhuan, Guoyu and Shiji.

The weakness of slips was their weight. The Hou Hanshu, in the biography of Cai Lun, writes: “From of old, books were mostly bound on bamboo slips, and those on fine silk were called paper. Silk was dear and slips were heavy, and neither was convenient. Lun conceived a plan: he made paper from bark, hemp ends, worn cloth and fishing nets,” so that “the whole world called it 'Marquis Cai's paper,'” which is the start of Paper Invention. The Taiping yulan, quoting the Huan Xuan weishi, records Huan Xuan saying: “In the old days there was no paper, so slips were used; it was not a matter of showing respect. Now those who use slips should all use yellow paper instead.” The quotation comes from an encyclopedia, so all that can be said is that Huan Xuan of the Eastern Jin is reported to have said it; the page gives no year.

The place of Slips & Scrolls was, before paper arrived, to turn argument, canon, historical record and the lists of chariots and horses buried with the dead into things that could be carried, kept and copied again; without them, the collating recorded in the Hanshu and the lost chapters in the Tsinghua slips could not be spoken of at all.

A slip held a couple of dozen characters, a book had to be loaded on a cart, Dongfang Shuo's memorial took two men to lift, and Liu Xiang could count how many slips were missing. On such carriers Hui Shi had his five carts of books, the Han court had its plan for storing books, and the chariot list of Marquis Yi of Zeng and the lost Shangshu chapters in the Tsinghua slips were buried and came back to light after more than two thousand years. Until Cai Lun's paper and Huan Xuan's yellow paper took over this weight, the words of the masters, the books of the historians and the characters of the classics all rode on slips and silk.

Slips & Scrolls is the class in the chapter on Crafts on the writing materials used before paper became common. Bamboo slips were already used for writing in the Shang, writing on slips and silk flourished in the Warring States, and only when Huan Xuan of the Eastern Jin ordered paper to replace slips did paper wholly take their place as the material for official documents. This class covers bamboo slips, wooden tablets and silk texts, and also surviving handwritten manuscripts, ancient maps, and archives and documents. The craft of making paper belongs to Paper Invention, printed books to Movable Type Printing, and painting and calligraphy to Painting & Xuan Paper.

Sources (14)
  1. 曾侯乙墓竹简展 (新华网)
  2. 档案学研究 2009 (纸代简牍)
  3. 尚书·多士
  4. 说文解字·叙
  5. 墨子·贵义
  6. 庄子·天下
  7. 史记·滑稽列传(东方朔)
  8. 汉书·艺文志
  9. 史记·太史公自序
  10. 后汉书·宦者列传(蔡伦)
  11. 太平御览·文部二十一(纸)
  12. 我国迄今发现时代最早的竹简在湖北展出
  13. 文明探源丨现存最早的竹简记录了曾侯乙下葬的“排场”
  14. 清华简:再证传世《尚书》确系伪本(北京日报,清华大学网站转载)