Stone seawalls along the Qiantang, from Five Dynasties bamboo-cage banks to Qing fish-scale walls, kept back the tide to protect Jiangnan farmland.

Five Dynasties to present
1012 · ImpactIn Dazhong Xiangfu 5 (1012), Hangzhou reported that the tide was battering the north-west bank of the Zhe River ever worse; in year 7 the transport commissioner Li Pu and others asked to use the old Qian method again, filling bamboo baskets with stone to make the bank (History of the Song, Treatise on Rivers and Canals).1659 · ImpactIn Shunzhi 16 (1659), the Supervising Secretary Zhang Weichi said that seven prefectures of Jiangsu and Zhejiang depended on the wall against the sea and that the Ming had specially levied sea-wall labour silver for yearly repairs (Draft History of the Qing, Treatise on Rivers and Canals).1736 · ImpactIn Qianlong 1 (1736), it was asked to build fish-scale great stone walls of over 6,000 zhang at Renhe, Haining and other places; the next year a fish-scale great stone wall of over 5,900 zhang was built from Puerdou in Haining to Jianshantou (Draft History of the Qing, Treatise on Rivers and Canals).1762 · ImpactIn Qianlong 27 (1762), on his southern tour, the emperor's edict called the sea wall the foremost protection of Yue and said that the brushwood wall stood on shifting sand where stone work could hardly be started, so only the brushwood wall could be strengthened (Draft History of the Qing, Treatise on Rivers and Canals).

The tide of the Qiantang River first became a problem for building a city. The Preparatory History of Wu-Yue (Wu Yue bei shi), under "(gengwu) year 4", records for the eighth lunar month: "The sea wall was first built. Because the river tide battered the site, the king ordered crossbowmen to shoot at the head of the tide, and so fixed its foundation, and then built the gates of Houchao, Tongjiang and others." It adds that "the sandy bank would not take rammed earth", that the king "ordered five hundred crossbowmen to shoot at the head of the tide", and "himself built the shrine of Mount Xu and wrote a poem, sealed in a box and placed at the sea gate", with the line "To tell the dragon spirit and the water lords: the Qiantang is borrowed to build Qian's city." "Then the head of the tide turned west to Xiling. The king ordered huge stones carried, filled into bamboo cages, and great timbers planted to hold them, and the foundations of the city were fixed." The page prints only "(gengwu) year 4", with no reign name; the History of the Song has "in the Kaiping years of the Liang", and 910 is this entry's conversion from the gengwu year.

The Song also wrote this into its treatise on rivers, and went on using the Qian method. The History of the Song (Song shi), "Treatise on Rivers and Canals", writes: "In the Kaiping years of the Liang, King Wusu of the Qian first built the sea wall", and "The tide battered it day and night and rammed earth would not hold, so he ordered several hundred crossbowmen to shoot at the head of the tide, and prayed at the shrine of Mount Xu." In Dazhong Xiangfu 5 (1012) Hangzhou reported that the Zhe River was "battering the north-west bank ever worse"; in year 7 the transport commissioner Li Pu and others surveyed it, judged the earlier brushwood-and-stake scheme of Qi Lun and others "not convenient", and "asked to use the old method of the Qian family again: put stones in bamboo baskets, pile them as a bank and fix them with timber piles, ringing it for some seven li". "In the Jingyou years, the stone sea wall of the Zhe River had long gone unmended and the people suffered flooding; Zhang Xia, a director in the Ministry of Works, was sent out, and set up five detachments of River-Guard soldiers to quarry stone and repair the wall, mending damage as it came, and the people trusted in it"; later "the people of the place built a shrine to him" and the court enfeoffed him as Marquis of Ningjiang. In the same chapter a memorial of Baoyou 3 writes: "In the Qingli years five River-Guard detachments were made." Jingyou and Qingli: the two statements differ, and they are set side by side here.

The wall is bound up with the rivers in the city. The History of the Song, "Treatise on Rivers and Canals", writes that the canal inside Lin'an "takes in the tide every day" and that "the silt and mud are muddy, silting up with each tide", and then carries a memorial of the prefect Su Shi from the Yuanyou years: he called out "River-Guard soldiers and the various garrison troops, a thousand men", and "within seven months dredged the Maoshan and Yanqiao canals, each over ten li", and asked for a lock to be placed in front of the Commandant's office, "and whenever the tide comes up, close this lock for the time". In Shaoxing 3 the emperor said: "We may send out the garrison troops of neighbouring commanderies, the city-wall troops and the River-Guard soldiers" to dredge the river, and "Yu lived in a poor house and gave his strength to the ditches; why trouble about idle talk?" The River-Guard soldiers set up to repair the wall are, in this chapter, also sent to dredge the river.

The Qing system is summed up in the Draft History of the Qing, "Treatise on Rivers and Canals": "Sea walls exist only in Jiangsu and Zhejiang. Walls are set along the sea coast to hold off the salt tide, to settle the people in their homes and make farming convenient." It also says: "From Tang and Song on they were repaired many times, but their form was incomplete. The Qing replaced earth walls with stone and made the repairs official instead of a charge on the people." In Shunzhi 16 the Supervising Secretary of the Office of Rites, Zhang Weichi said: "The seven prefectures of Hang, Jia, Hu, Ning, Shao, Su and Song all face the sea and depend on the wall to hold it off; at Haiyan, between two hills, the tide is fiercest. So the Ming specially levied sea-wall labour silver for yearly repairs." In Kangxi 3, "the sea at Haining rose and breached the wall for over 2,300 zhang". The treatise also says that in Zhejiang the sea wall "from the Wulong temple in Renhe to the border of Jinshan in Jiangnan is over 37,200 zhang long", and that "in Zhejiang the river water runs down and the sea tide runs up the river; the clash and surge are fiercer and more dangerous still". In Yongzheng 6, "the name 'emergency repair' began from this"; an edict of year 11 said: "If the work is made lasting and can protect the people's livelihood, no cost, even ten million, is to be spared." In Qianlong 1 (1736), "Zengyun asked to build fish-scale great stone walls of over 6,000 zhang at Renhe, Ninghai and other places", and the next year "a fish-scale great stone wall of over 5,900 zhang was built from Puerdou in Haining to Jianshantou". In Qianlong 45 the memorial of Agui and others describes how a fish-scale stone wall is made: "according to the height of the ground, sixteen to eighteen courses".

The edicts of the Qianlong reign do not take one tone. In year 27 an edict calls the sea wall "the foremost protection of Yue", which is the edict's own wording, and in the same edict says "the brushwood wall is on shifting sand and stone work can hardly be started", so only the brushwood wall could be strengthened; in year 30 an edict says "the stone wall round the city is truly the protection of the whole city"; in year 37 an edict says: "The shifting of the tide is the natural breathing in and out; to cut a diversion channel would probably be labour for nothing. It should be enough to guard the dykes with real effort and wait for the tide to go back by itself to its old course; there is no need to insist on cutting channels to lead the current, wanting to defeat the sea by human strength." In year 49 he also ordered "an allocation of five million". From these records, mending the wall was both engineering and something the court settled again and again.

Set beside other canons, a few points join. The entry Grand Canal is about the north-south waterway; in Su Shi's memorial the canal inside Hangzhou is repeatedly silted by the tide. The entry Yellow River Harnessing is about governing the Yellow River; the Draft History of the Qing writes the sea wall into its treatise on rivers, in the same chapter as the Huai and the Yongding. The entries Rice and Plant Foods are about rice and millet, and the entry Animal Foods is about domestic animals; the Qing history's "to settle the people in their homes and make farming convenient" is a line tying the sea wall to farming.

From these records, the wall keeps the tide off the towns and fields: the History of the Song writes that when the stone wall "had long gone unmended" the people "suffered flooding", and that after repair "the people trusted in it"; but the wall is not a once-and-for-all work: Li Qu's memorial says the River-Guard detachments were each set at four hundred men and "now only three hundred are on the books", and the Qing edicts and memorials were still discussing brushwood walls and stone walls.

King Wusu of the Qian ordered crossbowmen to shoot at the tide and then built the sea wall of stones in bamboo cages; the Song used "the old method of the Qian family" again and set up River-Guard soldiers to quarry stone and repair the wall, and those soldiers were also sent to dredge the canals of Hangzhou; the Qing replaced earth walls with stone, built a fish-scale great stone wall of over 5,900 zhang on the Puerdou to Jianshantou stretch of Haining alone, and Qianlong's edicts at once called the sea wall "the foremost protection of Yue" and said "there is no need to insist on cutting channels to lead the current, wanting to defeat the sea by human strength". The weight of the sea wall lies in a wall that was repaired generation after generation.

Stone Seawall Engineering is the class in the chapter on Infrastructure on the stone seawalls that hold back the tide along the Qiantang River. From the bamboo cages of stone of the Five Dynasties, to the dressed-stone wall of the Northern Song, to the fish-scale stone walls of the Qing, the way the wall was built changed step by step, guarding the farmland of Jiangnan.

Sources (5)
  1. 钱塘的“塘”是海塘的“塘” (Hangzhou News)
  2. Hangzhou News on Qiantang seawall history
  3. 維基文庫《吳越備史》卷2
  4. 維基文庫《宋史·河渠志七》
  5. 維基文庫《清史稿·河渠志三》