The principle of honesty in personal conduct and social life, stressing that one's word should be kept and verifiable. Confucius saw trust as the basis of a person's standing, and in the Western Han Dong Zhongshu listed it among the Five Constants.

Zhou dynasty to present
534 BCE · OriginThe Zuozhuan (Duke Zhao, year 8) records Shuxiang saying "a gentleman's words are trustworthy and verifiable," using verifiability to mark credible speech.500 BCE · EvolutionConfucius said "a person without good faith — I do not see how he can manage," making trust the foundation of personal conduct.300 BCE · EvolutionIn the Warring States Mencius said that "the great man's words need not be kept, his acts need not be carried through; he goes only where rightness lies", and counted "between friends, good faith" among the human relations (Mencius, Lilou II; Teng Wen Gong I).134 BCE · ImpactIn the Western Han, Dong Zhongshu named benevolence, righteousness, ritual, wisdom and trust the Five Constants, bringing trust into state ethics.

In the spring of the eighth year of Duke Zhao of Lu (534 BCE), the Zuo Tradition records that "a stone spoke at Weiyu in Jin". The Marquis of Jin asked Shi Kuang, who answered: "Stones cannot speak." He went on: "When works are undertaken out of season, resentment stirs among the people, and then things that do not speak will speak. Now the palaces are lofty and extravagant, and the people's strength is exhausted." At the time the Marquis was building the Siqi Palace. Shuxiang, hearing this, said: "Ziye's words are those of a gentleman! A gentleman's words are trustworthy and verifiable, so resentment keeps far from him; a petty man's words are false and unverifiable, so resentment and blame fall on him." (Zuo Tradition, Duke Zhao, year 8) This is where "trustworthy and verifiable" gets its original sense: words are credible because there is evidence that can be checked.

Confucius put trust at the foundation of a person's standing: "A person without good faith, I do not see how he can manage. A large cart without a yoke-bar, a small cart without a collar-bar: how can they be made to go?" (Analects, Weizheng) When Zigong asked about government, Confucius said it needed enough food, enough arms and the trust of the people; if something had to go, first arms, then food, for "since antiquity all have died, but without trust a people cannot stand" (Analects, Yan Yuan). Governing a state also rests on trust: "To lead a state of a thousand chariots, be reverent in affairs and trustworthy, frugal in spending and caring for people, and employ the people at the proper seasons" (Analects, Xue'er); to Fan Chi he said, "if those above love good faith, the people will not dare to be insincere" (Analects, Zilu). Yet he did not prize holding to one's word at any cost: when Zigong asked what makes a true officer, Confucius placed "one whose words must be kept and whose acts must be carried through, stubborn as a stone, a petty man" in the third grade (Analects, Zilu). Mencius said it more bluntly: "The great man's words need not be kept, his acts need not be carried through; he goes only where rightness lies." (Mencius, Lilou II) Among the human relations he listed is "between friends, good faith" (Mencius, Teng Wen Gong I). In the Western Han, Dong Zhongshu in his answers to the throne joined good faith with benevolence, rightness, ritual and wisdom as "the way of the five constants", which he said the king should cultivate and keep in order (Book of Han, Biography of Dong Zhongshu); trust thus passed from the basis of personal standing into the framework of state ethics.

Whether orders could be carried out depended on whether the people believed them. In Shang Yang's reforms, the new laws were ready but not yet announced, and "fearing that the people would not believe them", he set up a log three zhang long at the south gate of the market in the Qin capital and offered ten gold to anyone who could move it to the north gate; no one dared, so he raised it to fifty gold; when one man moved it, "he was at once given fifty gold, to show there was no deceit", and then "the order was finally issued" (Records of the Grand Historian, Biography of Lord Shang). Trust also came to rest on evidence. The Lesser Steward section of the Rites of Zhou lists the "eight records" by which offices handled affairs, among them "hearing debts by the split tally", "hearing gifts and receipts by written contract" and "hearing sales by the purchase deed": disputes over loans, giving and selling were settled by the written instruments. The Shuowen Jiezi defines fu, the tally: "Trust. Under the Han system it was made of bamboo, six cun long, split and matched together." Here "trust" is something that can be put together and checked, exactly the sense of "verifiable".

Trust also entered everyday speech and the raising of children. The Biographies of Ji Bu and Luan Bu in the Records of the Grand Historian record a saying of the people of Chu: "A hundred jin of gold is not worth one promise from Ji Bu." A man's promise was weighed against gold. The Hanfeizi tells how Zengzi's wife carelessly promised their child to kill a pig when she came back; Zengzi meant to do it, saying: "A child is not someone to joke with... If a mother deceives her child, the child will not believe its mother, and that is no way to teach." And so "the pig was cooked". The story says that teaching a child to keep faith begins with adults not deceiving the child.

Trust both checks and supports several other canons. With Righteousness: Master You said "good faith comes close to rightness, for one's word can be made good" (Analects, Xue'er), and Mencius said "he goes only where rightness lies", so trust is measured by rightness. With Contractual Credit Culture: the Rites of Zhou settled disputes over loans and sales by split tallies, written contracts and purchase deeds, so that trust took the form of documents that could be matched. With Benevolence: Dong Zhongshu set benevolence and good faith together among the five constants, and from then on trust and benevolence were both treated as constant virtues promoted by the state. With Art of War: among a general's five virtues, "wisdom, good faith, benevolence, courage and strictness", good faith stands second. With Primary Education: the story of Zengzi killing the pig is precisely about teaching faith from early childhood.

Trust turned a spoken word into something that could be checked: Shuxiang used "verifiable" to pick out a gentleman's words, Shang Yang used a log and fifty gold to make the people believe the law, the Rites of Zhou settled suits by written instruments, and the Shuowen defined the tally as "trust". It was also placed among the court's five constants, a general's virtues and the upbringing of children. Confucius and Mencius both warned that trust must answer to rightness and not be held to stubbornly. From the stone at Weiyu to the promise of Ji Bu, trust has always asked one question: do these words match the facts?

Trust is the class in the chapter on Values on good faith: the rule of keeping one's word and speaking what can be verified, in one's own conduct and in dealing with others. The Zuo Tradition records Shuxiang saying "a gentleman's words are trustworthy and verifiable", Confucius took trust as the foundation of personal conduct, and in the Western Han Dong Zhongshu listed it among the Five Constants.

Sources (16)
  1. Chunqiu Zuozhuan — Zhao Gong (ctext.org)
  2. Wujing — Britannica
  3. 春秋左氏傳·昭公(八年)
  4. 論語·爲政第二
  5. 論語·顏淵第十二
  6. 論語·學而第一
  7. 論語·子路第十三
  8. 孟子·離婁下
  9. 孟子·滕文公上
  10. 漢書·董仲舒傳(卷五十六)
  11. 史記·商君列傳(卷六十八)
  12. 周禮·天官冢宰(小宰)
  13. 說文解字·卷五(竹部)
  14. 史記·季布欒布列傳(卷一百)
  15. 韓非子·外儲說左上
  16. 孫子兵法(始計第一)