Merchant groups such as those of Huizhou, Shanxi, Fujian and Guangdong, using shared stock, home-place trust and long-distance trade to link the goods of different regions.

Ming dynasty to Republican era
1370 · OriginThe History of the Ming, Treatise on Food and Money, records that in the third year of Hongwu the Shanxi provincial government asked that merchants deliver rice to the Datong and Taiyuan granaries and be given small licences of Huai salt; the treatise calls summoning merchants to deliver grain in return for salt kaizhong.1492 · EvolutionThe History of the Ming, Treatise on Food and Money, records that in the fifth year of Hongzhi Ye Qi, Minister of Revenue, asked that merchants be called to pay silver to the salt transport office, and the treatise says the kaizhong method of going to the frontier was abandoned and the merchants' farms were dismantled.1830 · ImpactThe Draft History of the Qing, Treatise on Food and Money, records that in the Daoguang years Lianghuai was due to sell over 1,600,000 licences of fixed salt a year but by the tenth year south Huai sold only 500,000; Tao Zhu then introduced ticket salt in the north Huai. (The page here says only "the tenth year"; following the Daoguang dating above it is read as 1830.)1997 · ImpactThe ancient city of Pingyao was inscribed on the World Heritage List in 1997; UNESCO's statement says Pingyao was the banking centre for the whole of China in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

Merchants have long had a place in the histories. The "Biographies of Money-Makers" in the Records of the Grand Historian (Shiji) opens by ranking the ways of dealing with such things: "The best is to follow them, the next to guide them by profit, the next to teach and exhort them, the next to regulate them, and the worst is to compete with them", and says that, since regions' products differ, one should "wait for the farmers to produce food, for the foresters to bring out the timber, for the craftsmen to make the goods, and for the merchants to circulate them". The Biographies contain no merchant groups, only this line of reasoning about the division of work; what follows is how Ming and Qing merchants made their trade within the state's salt rules.

In the Ming it began with the frontier's lack of grain. The Mingshi (History of the Ming), in its Treatise on Food and Money, says: "Of the Ming salt rules, none was better than kaizhong." In the third year of Hongwu, the Shanxi provincial government reported that army grain was carried far and at great cost to Datong and asked that "merchants be ordered to deliver one shi of rice to the Datong granary and one shi three dou to the Taiyuan granary, and be given one small licence of Huai salt"; the emperor "followed it". The treatise explains: "Calling on merchants to deliver grain and giving them salt in return is called kaizhong." It adds that "in the early Ming, at each frontier, merchants under kaizhong recruited people to farm, and built terraces and forts to gather and defend themselves". The third year of Hongwu is 1370. This page records the Shanxi government's proposal and where kaizhong came from; it does not say that Shanxi merchants arose from it.

The method later changed. The History of the Ming writes: "In the fifth year of Hongzhi, the merchants were troubled by waiting to draw their salt, and Ye Qi, Minister of Revenue, asked that merchants be called to pay silver to the salt transport office, to be sent in bulk to the Imperial Granary and divided among the frontiers." The treatise goes on: "But the kaizhong method of going to the frontier was abandoned, the merchants' farms were dismantled", and frontier stores "grew emptier day by day". The fifth year of Hongzhi is 1492. The salt licence changed from being bought with grain to being bought with silver, and merchants no longer needed to farm at the frontier; these are the consequences the treatise sets down.

The Wuzazu already sets the merchants of two places side by side. It says: "Of the wealthy who rank highest, south of the Yangtze it is Xin'an, north of it Shanxi." Xin'an's great merchants "live by fish and salt, and some keep as much as a million in stored silver"; the people of Shanxi "deal in salt, or silk, or trading on, or storing grain, and their wealth exceeds Xin'an's", and it adds, "Xin'an is extravagant, Shanxi frugal." The page does not give the year the book was written, and this entry gives none.

Why people of Huizhou went out to trade is explained in a birthday preface Gui Youguang wrote for an old man named Cheng: "Today Xin'an has many great lineages, but their land lies in the mountain valleys with no plains or open fields to farm, so even the families of scholar-officials all go out to trade in the four directions." He says that wherever there are great cities, "houses stand in rows and shops line up" and "most are Xin'an people"; of Mr Cheng he asks, "is he not what is called a scholar who trades?" and then "is he not what is called a trader who is a scholar?" Great lineages, mountain land and scholars are set side by side by this author.

What marked Shanxi merchants is recorded in the Qing bai lei chao under remittance houses: a piaohao is one that "deals in remittances and lending; at first it was mostly Shanxi people who did it, with branches in every province"; its capital was raised by "those who put in money holding silver shares, those who put in labour holding body shares"; and "Shanxi remittance houses have always valued trust, not written contracts, and made no loans on pledges". The same book says Shanxi piaohao were "founded in the late Ming", began to flourish after the Qianlong and Jiaqing reigns, and "were at their height in the Tongzhi and Guangxu years", and that in the Xuantong reign there were twenty-two houses, "twenty-one of them Shanxi". The same page has two other accounts: a legend tied to Li Zicheng ("it is said ... were drawn up by Gu Yanwu"), and the statement that "Rishengchang was the first founded of the piaohao" and "in the early Daoguang years turned to remittance". The accounts stand on one page and are set side by side here. UNESCO's statement on the ancient city of Pingyao says Pingyao was the banking centre for the whole of China in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

The change in the Qing is recorded in the Draft History of the Qing (Qingshi gao), in its Treatise on Food and Money, under Huai salt: in the Daoguang years, "the Lianghuai salt smugglers grew more numerous by the day and the salt administration worse. At Lianghuai, over 1,600,000 licences of the fixed salt were due each year. By the tenth year, south Huai sold only 500,000." Following the Daoguang dating above, this is 1830. Tao Zhu, who took over, introduced ticket salt in the north Huai, with ten articles of regulation: "four hundred jin of salt is one licence, which comes to 0.64 liang of silver, and with all the various fees, 1.88 liang"; the treatise says that "once people saw its advantage, from far and near they converged, salt boats came to the landings prow to stern, as had not happened in decades". Another sentence in the treatise explains the old method: "Licensed merchants had an exclusive territory, called the licence area. When first taking it up they paid dearly, so it was held as a hereditary property, called the licence seat."

Taken together these pages show the relation between merchants and the state: kaizhong was the state using merchants to carry grain, the salt licence became a "licence seat" that could be passed on, and with ticket salt it was again the state that changed the method. As for the merchant groups' joint stock, home-place ties and lineages, the pages hold only fragments: Gui Youguang writes of the great lineages of Xin'an, the Qing bai lei chao writes of silver shares and body shares; how these formed a merchant group the pages do not say in detail, and this entry does not fill it in for them.

Merchant Guild Commerce is linked to several other canons. Salt & Transit Monopolies covers the state's control of salt profits; kaizhong, salt licences and ticket salt are all about how the state handed salt to merchants to carry and sell. Lineage Trust Funds covers clan property and charitable estates; the "many great lineages" of Xin'an that Gui Youguang writes of meet it in the villages. Shanxi Remittance Houses covers remittances by piaohao, and Pingyao is known for banking in UNESCO's statement. Contractual Credit Culture covers contracts as proof, yet the Qing bai lei chao says Shanxi remittance houses "have always valued trust, not written contracts"; reading the two together is this entry's own reading. Currency Evolution covers silver; the paying of silver in the Hongzhi years is one point where merchants and money meet.

The state needed the merchants, and the merchants' coming and going touched the state. Kaizhong handed the frontier's grain to merchants to carry, and once silver was paid instead the treatise wrote "the merchants' farms were dismantled" and frontier stores "grew emptier day by day"; by the Daoguang years it writes that at Lianghuai "the salt smugglers grew more numerous by the day and the salt administration worse". The merchants did trade, yet in these pages they are tied to army grain and salt revenue.

The Records of the Grand Historian say merchants "circulate" goods, the History of the Ming records "calling on merchants to deliver grain and giving them salt in return", the Wuzazu compares Xin'an and Shanxi, Gui Youguang writes of "a scholar who trades", and the Qingshi gao writes of Huai salt moving to ticket salt. In these pages merchants are a group the officials relied on to carry grain and sell salt, and for whom scholars wrote birthday prefaces; how the merchant group itself was formed has to be filled in from other materials. Their place ran from the frontier granary and the salt licence at one end to the great lineages of the villages at the other.

Merchant Guild Commerce is the class in the chapter on Commerce on the merchant groups: the merchant-group economy from the Ming to the Republican era, represented by the Huizhou, Shanxi, Fujian and Guangdong merchants. Traders from the same home place and clan did business on trust between fellow natives, shared capital and long-distance carrying, crossing the barriers that separated the goods of different regions.

Sources (10)
  1. 明朝的經濟:以徽商、晉商為例 (lecture notes PDF)
  2. 徽商兴衰 (aisixiang)
  3. 維基文庫《史記·貨殖列傳》(卷129)
  4. 維基文庫《明史·食貨志四》(鹽法,卷80)
  5. 維基文庫《五雜俎》卷4
  6. 維基文庫《白庵程翁八十壽序》(歸有光,出《震川先生集》卷13)
  7. 維基文庫《清史稿·食貨志四》(鹽法,卷123)
  8. 維基文庫《清稗類鈔·農商類·山西票號》
  9. Ancient City of Ping Yao (UNESCO WHC 812)
  10. 日升日又落——日升昌的衰亡