Northern Song Sichuan used iron cash. The Songchao shishi (Facts of the Song Dynasty), juan 15, records a memorial from Zhang Ruogu, the transport commissioner, and Xue Tian, prefect of Yizhou: "In the Sichuan region iron cash is used; the small coins weigh sixty-five jin per ten strings, and converted to large coins one string weighs twelve jin. In street trading, once a sale reaches three or five strings it is hard to carry." He Ping, a professor at Renmin University of China, adds a layer in the Guangming Daily (22 January 2024, reposted on the website of the National Office for Philosophy and Social Sciences): the Sichuan iron-cash zone was itself a special arrangement made by the Northern Song court when copper cash was short; in its early days jiaozi "only served large transactions, while daily trade still needed small iron coins."
Early jiaozi were private notes, and two books tell it differently. The Song shi says that when Zhang Yong governed Shu under Emperor Zhenzong he set up a scheme of tallies, "one note for one string, exchanged every three years as one issue," and that "sixteen wealthy households ran it"; the Songchao shishi instead writes that "more than a hundred thousand wealthy households of Yizhou stood surety together to make jiaozi," that cashing a string "cut thirty coins as profit," and that when crowds came for their money the printers "shut their doors and did not come out," so that payment came to "at most seven or eight hundred per string." Sixteen households in one book and over a hundred thousand in the other: they are set side by side here, not merged.
How the state took over is also told three ways. The Song shi says the transport commissioners Xue Tian and Zhang Ruogu "asked to set up the Yizhou Jiaozi Bureau"; the Songchao shishi first records the prefect Kou Jian urging the jiaozi houses to "close their jiaozi shops," Kou's request that "from now on the people must not set up jiaozi shops as before," and the court's order that Zhang Ruogu and Xue Tian decide the matter; the main text of the Huangsong tongjian changbian jishi benmo says that Xue Tian, as transport commissioner, "asked for an official jiaozi bureau," while Kou Jian, governing Shu, "asked to abolish jiaozi and use them no more." Its small note adds that the Veritable Records and the Treatise on Food and Goods both name Kou Jian as the one who asked, while the biography appended to Xue Tian's makes it Xue Tian; the annotator concludes "the bureau as set up followed Tian's proposal; Jian had no part in it," and says the Veritable Records, the appended biography, the main biography and the Treatise on Food and Goods "are all mistaken." Whether Kou or Xue asked is not decided here.
The Songchao shishi records the dates: "On the 28th day of the 11th month of Tiansheng 1 it reached the prefecture; from the 20th day of the 2nd month of year 2 writing began; after a full year, 3,884,600 strings of the second issue had been put out." The months and days are lunar; He Ping gives Tiansheng 1 as 1023 and says official jiaozi were issued the next year. Each note was "in width and size just as the people had issued them, stamped with the prefecture's bronze seal," and on each string of iron cash "thirty coins were deducted for the state." The Song shi adds that "each issue was fixed at 1,256,340 strings" and that each issue kept "360,000 strings of capital," and He Ping gives the reserve ratio as 28.65 percent. The amount put out and the fixed quota do not agree between the two books; both are stated.
Jiaozi soon spread beyond Sichuan. On the 3rd day of the 2nd month (lunar) of Huangyou 3 (1051), the finance commissioner Tian Kuang reported that Qinzhou had twice borrowed 600,000 strings of jiaozi, "with no cash set aside, only printing in vain," so that "the original rule was already spoiled"; He Ping places the two uses of 600,000 strings of Yizhou jiaozi in Shaanxi "in Qingli 7 (1047) and before." The Song shi says that in the Daguan years of war the issue was "more than twenty times one issue of Tiansheng, and the value fell further," and that "the qianyin were meant to stand in for salt vouchers." For the Southern Song official huizi the Song shi says "in year 30 the vice-minister Qian Duanli was ordered to make huizi"; He Ping dates it Shaoxing 31 (1161), a year later; both are given. The Song shi also quotes Han Xiang of Chunyou 2: "What ruins paper money is only change; nothing saves it like withdrawing and reducing."
The Yuan went on using paper. The Yuan shi says that in Zhongtong 1 (1260) the court "first made jiaochao, with silk as the base," and in the 10th month (lunar) made the Zhongtong yuanbao notes, "each string equal to one tael of jiaochao, two strings equal to one tael of white silver"; in Zhiyuan 24 (1287), because "goods were dear and notes cheap," it made the Zhiyuan notes, "each string equal to five strings of Zhongtong notes," and "counterfeiters of notes were put to death." The opening of the treatise calls the note law "mother and child weighed against each other, in the meaning of the Zhou officials' zhiji." In Zhida 2 (1309) the Zhida silver notes were added, and the treatise says "the Yuan note law had by now changed three times." He Ping holds that the nationwide use of Yuan notes was "not the result of market growth" (he cites Wang Wencheng and others).
Ming treasure notes went to the other extreme. He Ping dates the Treasure Note Office to Hongwu 7 (1374), with the Great Ming Treasure Notes made the next year. The Ming shi records that each note "was equal to a thousand coins or one tael of silver" and that "the people were forbidden to trade in gold, silver or goods"; in early Xuande "a shi of rice took fifty strings of notes," under the Chenghua emperor "a string of notes could not fetch one coin," and in Jiajing 4 "a string of notes was reckoned at three li of silver." He Ping calls it a state paper money "without reserve, without redemption, without limit on quantity," says traditional Chinese paper money was "precocious but not mature," and sees it ending in the silver age of "money without institutions."
This canon touches others. The coinage in Currency Evolution runs alongside notes here, and the Ming shi writes "the Great Ming Treasure Notes were to circulate together with the coins of past reigns"; the salt revenue in Salt & Transit Monopolies is joined to it by the Song shi's statement that qianyin were meant to replace salt vouchers; the zhiji of Contractual Credit Culture is what the Yuan shi uses to explain the note; and the remittance houses of Shanxi Remittance Houses were, in Liu Chenghu's view, "founded" by Pingyao merchants after they drew on the experience of "flying cash and huizi," while the Song shi already says that huizi and jiaozi "took something from the Tang flying cash." The standard histories of the Song, Yuan and Ming each gave note law space.
Iron cash in Sichuan weighed "one string twelve jin," and "once a sale reaches three or five strings it is hard to carry": that is where jiaozi began. The private notes were "exchanged every three years as one issue"; once the state set up its bureau, the Song shi records a fixed quota for each issue and "360,000 strings of capital." By the Daguan years the issue was "more than twenty times one issue of Tiansheng, and the value fell further"; the Yuan fixed notes to silk and to silver, and the Ming treasure notes, called by He Ping "without reserve, without redemption, without limit on quantity," ended in the silver age of "money without institutions." The standard histories of the Song, Yuan and Ming all gave the note law space.
Jiaozi Banknotes is the class in the chapter on Commerce on the paper money of the Northern Song to the Ming: in 1023 (Tiansheng 1) the Yizhou Jiaozi Bureau was set up and the next year issued official jiaozi, for which the Song shi records a fixed quota and reserve funds for each issue; the Yuan ran the Zhiyuan notes alongside the Zhongtong notes, and the Ming issued the Great Ming Treasure Note.